An analysis of the battle of passchendaele casualties

The battle ended on 10 November, apart from small operations. The troops would be supported in Pilcken by massive formations of tanks and attack proved initially successful but, unfortunately, the troops of the right flank were blocked and failed to achieve his goal: Carbery, in The New Zealand Medical Service in the Great War —gave estimated figures that were nearer the truth for fatalities on 12 October, if we accept that most of the missing were in fact dead: Yet the flatness of the plain made stealth impossible: Australian troops on standby were bombarded with heavy mortars in their trenches and, as reached the top, were overtaken by German troops advancing under cover of the barrage, by coincidence the enemy troops had launched an assault at the same time.

On September 26 the weather was still good and the ground had dried up, that day the saturation barrage of Plumer worked well and the Anzacs could proceed under such coverage, very quickly. The Germans were eventually driven back by charging with fixed bayonets of Australians, however the German machine guns were causing increasing casualties and retained part of the attack.

The British and French commanders on the Western Front had to reckon on the German western army Westheer being strengthened by reinforcements from the Ostheer on the Eastern Front by late Macmullen of GHQ proposed that the plateau be taken by a mass tank attack, reducing the need for artillery; in April a reconnaissance by Captain G.

Between the German defences lay villages such as Zonnebeke and Passchendaele, which were fortified and prepared for all-round defence. His main aim was a breakthrough to the coast of Belgium so that German submarine pens could be destroyed.

The land seized was consolidated and backed by a railway line and secondary r Australian soldiers fighting at Polygon Wood oads were quickly opened to allow the rapid arrival of new supplies to the front. Planning to launch an attack from the Ypres Salient, General Haig planned An analysis of the battle of passchendaele casualties push across the Gheluvelt Plateau, take Passchendaele, and then break through to an open country.

They were sixty metres high at the most. The lowland west of the ridge, was a mixture of meadow and fields, with high hedgerows dotted with trees, cut by streams and a network of drainage ditches emptying into canals. Haig argued that any German loss of men was of greater importance than British loss as the Allies could sustain more losses as America had joined the war by the end of Passchendaele Share with friends.

It was not a torrencial rain, but a fine persistent rain. Once men were evacuated from the front, units had little knowledge of their disposition.

Gradients vary from negligible, to 1: How to determine the number of men who actually lost their lives as a result of the attack on 12 October? Those three wins were credited to the overwhelming success of the technique step-by-step guide on Plumer and were possible only because the weather had been dry enough to allow the mud to dry.

Even reaching the goal, he was useless in terms of the original plan: Therefore, the German army in the area fully expected a major Allied attack — so any vague hope of surprise was lost, as was true in any attack that started with a major artillery bombardment.

Other operations were begun by the British to regain territory or to evict the Germans from ground overlooking their positions. At this point their artillery was almost out of ammunition and its projectile, when fired, were buried in mud, causing very little impact on the enemy Haig was still clung to the battle, even with the rain and cold that came on Oct.

His reasons were to continue to allow their troops to winter in the ravine, without which the Germans might be able to target and "drier", once the front line would be beyond the swamp.

He suggested that the southern attack from St Yves to Mont Sorrel should come first and that Mont Sorrel to Steenstraat should be attacked within 48—72 hours. Western Front World War I and Nivelle Offensive Nivelle planned an operation in three parts, with preliminary offensives to pin German reserves by the British at Arras and the French between the Somme and the Oisethen a French breakthrough offensive on the Aisnefollowed by pursuit and exploitation.

The 4th Australian Division then took the rest of the Polygon wood area, or what was left of it. The coastal strip is sandy but a short way into the hinterland, the ground rises towards the Vale of Ypres, which before was a flourishing market garden.

Even a partial success would improve the tactical situation in the Ypres salient, reducing wastage, which was exceptional, even in quiet periods.

Such a philosophy would lead to a tremendous concentration of power in a relatively small front, which facilitates the exchange of tired men and the distribution of food and ammunition. Aerial photographs were taken after the battle of Passchendaele, an estimated half a million bullets holes could be seen in half a square mile of the city.

Although the Field Marshal Sir Douglas Haig had proposed a short battle in order to penetrate the German lines, it was patently impossible now, he still insisted on continuing to Battle of Langemark at north.

Analysis of a list of men who died of wounds in Belgium from 12 October to 12 November supplied by the CWGC indicated that three men with death dates of 12 October had been wounded on either 4 or 10 October.

They lostmen. Haig had long wanted a British offensive in Flanders and, following a warning that the German blockade would soon cripple the British war effort, wanted to reach the Belgian coast to destroy the German submarine bases there.

Shows one reading jokes from the publication "NZ at the Front" to a wounded man on a stretcher. Nivelle agreed to a proviso that if the first two parts of the operation failed to lead to a breakthrough, the operations would be stopped so that the British could move their forces north for the Flanders offensive, which Haig stressed was of great importance to the British government.

An analysis of the battle of passchendaele casualties

He suggested that the southern attack from St Yves to Mont Sorrel should come first and that Mont Sorrel to Steenstraat should be attacked within 48—72 hours.

During the First World War determining exact casualty figures, especially those occurring in major battles, was usually very difficult.

Second Battle of Passchendaele

Image courtesy of Alexander Turnbull Library, Ref: A century ago, roads in the area were unpaved, except for the main ones from Ypres, with occasional villages and houses dotted along them.

The final objectives were largely gained before dark and the British had fewer losses than the expected 50 percent in the initial attack. The second of two attacks made by New Zealand troops during the Third Battle of Ypres, it was a disastrous fiasco.The Battle of Passchendaele (or Third Battle of Ypres or "Passchendaele") Analysis.

Third Battle of Ypres German casualties: Date Total casualties Missing neglected to deduct 75, British casualties for the Battle of Cambrai given in the Official Statistics, Disputed ,–, Disputed, ,–, including 24, prisoners.

` 1. Even though Source B was a first hand account and A was not, this does not mean that A is not useful. Every Source is a useful source. Source A is good because it is factual. I know this because it is written for a textbook, which also means that it is an unbiased account. It tells is.

It was also in the trenches at the second Battle of Ypres that John McCrae wrote the poem when a close friend was killed, one of Canadian casualties in just 48 hours. An analysis of the battle of passchendaele casualties Published March 30, | By Euclid, seized and glamorous, revalues her an analysis of the battle of passchendaele.

Casualties and losses;–, –The Battle of Passchendaele was one of the biggest battles of the First World War. It happened between July and November The Battle of Passchendaele was one of the biggest battles of the First World War.

It happened between July and November The Battle of Passchendaele, also known as the third battle of Ypres, was fought between July and November of Background to the Battle In November ofAllied leaders met to discuss plans for the upcoming year.

Download
An analysis of the battle of passchendaele casualties
Rated 3/5 based on 94 review